Just another iHealthSpot WP02 site

Joint Replacement Institute
  • (239) 261-2663
  • Patient Portal
  • Online Bill Pay
  • Request an Appointment
MENUMENU
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Meet Our Team
    • H. Kurtis Biggs, DO
    • Brian Wallace, DO
    • Paul Beebe, MD
    • J. Scott Herron, MD
    • Cody Togher, DPM
    • Zachary Elstad, MD
    • Benjamin Schnee, DO
    • Physician Assistants
    • Physical Therapy Team
  • Conditions We Treat
    • Arthritis
    • Bursitis
    • Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
    • Cartilage Tears
    • Elbow Pain
    • Foot & Ankle Injuries
    • Fractures & Dislocations
    • Hand & Wrist Injuries
    • Hip & Knee Injuries
    • Hip Pain
    • Knee Pain
    • Ligament Disruptions
    • Neck & Back Pain
    • Repetitive Stress Disorders
    • Shoulder Pain
    • Spinal Conditions
    • Sports Injuries
    • Sprains
    • Tendonitis
    • Work-Related Injuries
  • Surgery Specialties
    • Arthroscopy
    • Foot & Ankle Surgery
    • Hand Surgery
    • Hip Surgery
    • Knee Surgery
    • Robotic Surgery
    • Shoulder Surgery
    • Spinal Surgery
    • Total Joint Replacement
  • On-Site Services & Products
    • Diagnostic Imaging
    • Injection Clinic
    • Pain Management
    • Patient-Specific Implants
    • Physical Therapy
    • Products
    • PRP Therapy
    • Sports Medicine
  • New Patients & Resources
    • Blog
    • Patient Education
    • Physician Referral
  • Reviews
  • Contact Us

When Is Surgery the Best Treatment for a Herniated Degenerative Disc

May 23, 2025

3D Illustration of the human spine with herniated disc.

Living with chronic back pain due to a herniated degenerative disc can feel overwhelming. Whether you are sitting, walking, or lying down, the discomfort never seems to completely subside.

For many individuals navigating this condition, there comes a point where conservative treatments are no longer effective. At that stage, questions about surgery as a solution often arise.

Let us discuss when surgery might be the best treatment for a herniated degenerative disc, the common surgery options, and how to decide if surgery is the best treatment for herniated degenerative disc.

What Is a Herniated Degenerative Disc

A herniated degenerative disc occurs when a spinal disc wears down due to aging or wear-and-tear and eventually bulges or ruptures. This condition can press on surrounding nerves, causing pain, numbness, or weakness, often in the back, neck, legs, or arms, depending on the affected area.

Spinal discs act as cushions between vertebrae. When they lose their integrity, symptoms such as shooting pain, limited movement, and discomfort may arise.

When Is Surgery the Best Treatment for a Herniated Degenerative Disc

Surgery is generally considered a last resort for a herniated degenerative disc, reserved for cases where other treatments, such as physical therapy, pain medications, or injections, have failed.

It is most appropriate when symptoms are severe and significantly impact daily life. Below are specific scenarios where surgery might be the best option.

1.     Persistent, Chronic Pain

If the pain caused by a herniated degenerative disc lasts longer than six weeks despite trying non-invasive treatments like physical therapy, anti-inflammatory medications, or epidural steroid injections, surgery may provide relief.

Persistent pain that radiates down the legs, commonly known as sciatica, is a key symptom that could indicate the need for surgery, as it suggests nerve compression.

2.     Neurological Symptoms

Neurological symptoms such as significant numbness, tingling, or weakness in the legs or feet are warning signs that the nerves are being compressed by the herniated disc. If left untreated, these symptoms can worsen over time and potentially lead to permanent nerve damage.

In these cases, surgery aims to relieve the pressure on the nerves and restore normal function.

3.     Loss of Bladder or Bowel Control

In rare and serious cases, a herniated degenerative disc can lead to cauda equina syndrome, a condition that compresses the bundle of nerves at the lower end of the spinal cord. This can result in symptoms such as bowel or bladder dysfunction, saddle numbness (loss of sensation in the groin), and severe weakness in the legs.

Cauda equina syndrome is a medical emergency that requires immediate surgical intervention to prevent permanent neurological damage.

4.     Limited Mobility and Reduced Quality of Life

Severe pain and reduced mobility can make performing everyday tasks like walking, bending, or even sitting down feel nearly impossible. If these symptoms are severely impacting your ability to work, perform daily activities, or enjoy your life, surgery may help restore mobility, reduce pain, and improve your overall quality of life.

Types of Surgeries for a Herniated Degenerative Disc

Several types of surgeries can address a herniated degenerative disc. Your doctor will recommend the most suitable option based on your symptoms and overall health.

1.     Microdiscectomy

This minimally invasive procedure is one of the most common surgeries for herniated discs. During a microdiscectomy, the surgeon removes the damaged portion of the disc that is pressing on the nerve.

2.     Laminectomy

A laminectomy involves removing part of the bone (the lamina) covering the spinal canal. This reduces pressure on the spinal cord or nerve roots.

3.     Spinal Fusion

Spinal fusion surgery may be recommended for individuals experiencing significant instability in the spine. It involves permanently connecting two or more vertebrae to prevent movement that causes pain.

4.     Artificial Disc Replacement

An artificial disc replacement involves removing the damaged disc and replacing it with an artificial one. This procedure helps to maintain mobility in the spine.

How to Decide If Surgery Is the Right Option

Deciding if surgery is the best treatment for a herniated degenerative disc involves careful consideration of several factors, including:

  • The severity of your symptoms.
  • The effectiveness of non-surgical treatments.
  • Your overall health and medical history.
  • The potential risks and benefits of surgery.

Your spine specialist will closely evaluate your situation and recommend a treatment plan tailored to your needs.

Best Treatment for a Herniated Degenerative Disc in Naples, FL

If you are still unsure about the best treatment for a herniated degenerative disc, expert guidance is only a consultation away. At the Joint Replacement Institute, our team of board-certified orthopedists specializes in spinal health and offers a range of advanced treatments to suit your condition and goals. Our specialists are committed to providing compassionate, high-quality care that meets your unique needs.

We offer:

  • Thorough evaluations to understand your condition
  • Personalized treatment plans tailored to your lifestyle
  • Access to cutting-edge surgical and non-surgical options
  • Ongoing support and rehabilitation to promote a full recovery

For more information or to schedule a consultation with one of our orthopedic specialists, call us today at (239) 261-2663 or use our convenient appointment request form. We look forward to serving you!

Filed Under: Herniated Degenerative Disc Tagged With: Artificial Disc Replacement, best treatment for a herniated degenerative disc, Best Treatment for a Herniated Degenerative Disc in Naples, herniated degenerative disc, orthopedic specialists, orthopedists, spinal cord, Spinal Fusion, spinal health, Spine Specialist

Primary Sidebar

Categories

  • Arthroscopic Surgery
  • Back Pain
  • Bunions
  • Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
  • Diabetic Foot Care
  • Fluoroscopy
  • Foot & Ankle Pain
  • Foot Care
  • Foot Doctor
  • Fractures & Dislocations
  • General
  • Heel Pain Treatment
  • Herniated Degenerative Disc
  • Hip Pain
  • Joint Replacement Surgery
  • Knee
  • Knee Replacement Surgery
  • MRI
  • Orthopedic doctor
  • Orthopedic Surgery
  • Orthopedics
  • Pain Management
  • Partial Knee Replacement
  • Peripheral Neuropathy
  • Physical Therapy
  • Plantar Fasciitis
  • Podiatrist
  • Podiatry
  • Posterior Tibial Tendon Dysfunction
  • PRP Therapy
  • Rheumatoid Arthritis
  • Robotic Surgery
  • Rotator Cuff Surgery
  • Shoulder Pain
  • Shoulder Replacement
  • Spinal Stenosis
  • Spine
  • Sports Injuries
  • Sports Medicine
  • Sprains & Strains
  • Stem Cell Therapy
  • Trigger Finger
  • Ultrasound

TAGS

Arthroscopic Knee Surgery Naples FL Arthroscopic Surgery Naples FL Arthroscopic Surgery near me best foot doctor near me best orthopedic doctor near me best podiatrist near me Foot and Ankle Doctor Foot and Ankle Doctor in Naples FL Foot and Ankle Doctor Naples FL Foot and Ankle Doctor near me Foot Doctor in Naples foot doctor near me Foot Doctor Near You foot pain treatment Naples FL foot pain treatment near me Foot Problems Hip Replacement Surgery Naples FL joint pain Joint Replacement Joint Replacement Institute Joint Replacement Surgeon Naples FL joint surgery orthopedic doctor in Naples FL orthopedic doctor near me Orthopedic Doctor Near You orthopedics orthopedic specialist near me Orthopedic Surgeon in Naples FL Orthopedic Surgeon near me Orthopedic Surgeons Naples FL Orthopedic Surgeons near me Orthopedic Surgery near me pain management Physical Therapy Podiatrist In Naples FL Podiatrist Naples FL Podiatrist near me Podiatrist Near You podiatry care Naples FL podiatry care near me Podiatry Office near me Reverse Shoulder Replacement Shoulder Replacement Surgery Sports Injuries Trusted Podiatrist In Naples FL

Footer

Patient Testimonials

We often hear from our patients about how the doctors and staff at the Joint Replacement Institute have helped them.

See More

The Joint
Replacement
Institute BLOG

Keep up with the latest developments in orthopedic care, as well as news about our practice and events we sponsor.

Learn More

Patient
Education
Library

Our patient education library features more than 200 award-winning articles with images, videos, and tons of helpful information.

Learn More

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Meet Our Team
  • Conditions We Treat
  • Surgery Specialties
  • On-Site Services & Products
  • New Patients & Resources
  • Reviews
  • Contact Us
  • Accessibility Statement
  • HIPAA Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap

The Joint Replacement Institute

(239) 261-2663 (BONE) Fax: (239) 262-5633 (KNEE)

Copyright © The Joint Replacement Institute. All Rights Reserved.

iHealthspot Medical Website Design and Medical Marketing by iHealthSpot.com

The Joint Replacement Institute in Naples, FL, offers Arthroscopy, Foot & Ankle Surgery, Hip Surgery, Knee Surgery, Robotic Surgery, Shoulder Surgery, and, Total Joint Replacement for a number of orthopedic conditions. In addition, we provide multiple on-site services and products.

MENUMENU
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Meet Our Team
    • H. Kurtis Biggs, DO
    • Brian Wallace, DO
    • Paul Beebe, MD
    • J. Scott Herron, MD
    • Cody Togher, DPM
    • Zachary Elstad, MD
    • Benjamin Schnee, DO
    • Physician Assistants
    • Physical Therapy Team
  • Conditions We Treat
    • Arthritis
    • Bursitis
    • Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
    • Cartilage Tears
    • Elbow Pain
    • Foot & Ankle Injuries
    • Fractures & Dislocations
    • Hand & Wrist Injuries
    • Hip & Knee Injuries
    • Hip Pain
    • Knee Pain
    • Ligament Disruptions
    • Neck & Back Pain
    • Repetitive Stress Disorders
    • Shoulder Pain
    • Spinal Conditions
    • Sports Injuries
    • Sprains
    • Tendonitis
    • Work-Related Injuries
  • Surgery Specialties
    • Arthroscopy
    • Foot & Ankle Surgery
    • Hand Surgery
    • Hip Surgery
    • Knee Surgery
    • Robotic Surgery
    • Shoulder Surgery
    • Spinal Surgery
    • Total Joint Replacement
  • On-Site Services & Products
    • Diagnostic Imaging
    • Injection Clinic
    • Pain Management
    • Patient-Specific Implants
    • Physical Therapy
    • Products
    • PRP Therapy
    • Sports Medicine
  • New Patients & Resources
    • Blog
    • Patient Education
    • Physician Referral
  • Reviews
  • Contact Us